Every November, Americans gather around tables to celebrate Thanksgiving. We tell ourselves a story of Pilgrims and Native Americans sharing a peaceful meal, a myth of harmony and gratitude. But the real power of Thanksgiving lies not in its origins, but in how leaders have used it to shape national identity during moments of crisis. In 1863, with the Union torn apart by a great Civil War, President Abraham Lincoln declared a National Day of Thanksgiving. His proclamation was not about Pilgrims; in fact, Pilgrims were never mentioned – it was about unity. Lincoln urged Americans to give thanks “in the midst of a civil war of unequaled magnitude and severity,” reframing suffering as part of divine providence and national resilience. Thanksgiving became a civic ritual of reconciliation, binding the North and South under shared values even as battlefields raged. By the late 19 th century, the Plymouth feast had become America’s founding story. Textbooks and school pageants promo...
Not a Democrat or Republican. Not Liberal and not Conservative. I am an Independent American: Follow me on Bluesky, I-Could-Be-Wrong, Written by David Pederson