There is so much going on today that figuring out what to
write about is hard. Do I write about Musk and DOGE? Do I write about Musk and
our military plans? Do I write about Trump and his deportations? I think I will
write about Trump wanting to shutter the Department of Education. Trump has now
signed an executive order to close the Department of Education, according to
NBC News. Trump has been promising that and now he has done it. I am sure there are going to be a lot of
lawsuits questioning whether Trump has the constitutional authority to shutter
it.
The Department of
Education was created by an Act of Congress during the Carter administration.
The Republican President, Ronald Reagan ran on closing it but was never able to
do it. George H. W. Bush wanted to be known as the Education President so it
went pretty much untouched during his administration. In the 90s with the Republican-controlled
Congress, stating they opposed the Department of Education, its funding grew by
that same Congress. George W. Bush had his” No Child Left Behind”. It is almost
like the Republicans have had a love-hate relationship. I too have had that
same love-hate relationship. I am an old guy and I was educated before the Department
of Education existed as a cabinet position. I will tell you that the schools in
Kenosha, Wisconsin were excellent when I was in school. The Kenosha school
districts had excellent programs like music and art.
The Department of Education does have a history before it
became a cabinet post under Carter. In 1867 a Department of Education was created
by legislation signed by Andrew Johnson. It was created to collect data about
schools and provide advice just like the Department of Agriculture did with farmers.
It became a bureau in the Department of the Interior known as the United States
Office of Education. Even back then people were concerned it would have too
much control over local schools. It had existed under various departments until
it became its own Cabinet department in 1979. My point is that all the way back
to 1867 the government recognized the need for a Department of Education in
some form. The four key functions of the Department of Education are 1)
establish policies on federal financial aid for education and distribution as
well as monitor those funds. 2) Collect data on the schools and disseminate
research. 3) Focus national attention on key issues in education, and make
recommendations for education reform. 4) Prohibiting discrimination and ensuring
equal access to education.
Will there be a huge change if Trump is successful in eliminating
the Department of Education? I don’t know for sure but I have many concerns. One
of my major concerns is with inclusion. When I was growing up, my hometown had
a separate school for children with physical and intellectual disabilities. Today,
children have been able to have the same school experience that every other
student which I feel is the right of every child. Not everyone agreed with their
inclusion in the regular classroom. They thought it took away from the classroom
for the so-called normal students. With the Department of Education no longer
being there to monitor civil rights will the rights of those disabled students
going to be taken away? Are they no longer going to be welcomed in a normal
classroom? They are part of the Inclusion that is part of DEI.
You could also call Inclusion as Handicap Rights. Many
things we have today are just part of everyday life because of inclusion:
sidewalk ramps, access ramps into restaurants, crosswalks that beep or
countdown for the handicapped, and elevators to improve handicapped access to
schools, jobs, and entertainment venues. If it starts with inclusion in the schools,
you will have a hard time convincing me that it will not spread to every aspect
of our society. Donald Trump has not shown very much empathy for the handicapped
in the past. While campaigning he mocked a handicapped reporter that asked a
question that he didn’t like. I have read an article where he told his nephew
he should just let his handicapped son die and move to Florida. Is Trump going
to return us to the day when students with disabilities were hidden away and taught
in the basements of schools? Are we going to institutionalize people again
because society doesn’t want to be inconvenienced by having them around? Will taxpayers deem it is just too expensive for
handicapped services including the services supplied by our schools?
I think when historians write about our society they will
not only write about the successes and failures we make but also about how we
treat the least of us by the people who have to most, who will be hurt the most
as the federal government cuts back not only the money and the oversite of our
schools. Even now you see many of our southern states like Oklahoma and Alabama
lag behind the northern states such as Massachusetts with school support. To give
more control to a State that already doesn’t value education will just hurt
those children in the state more. States
that ban books will continue to stifle the learning of the children within that
state. Oklahoma, a state that wants the Ten Commandments and the Bible in every
school has one of the worst school systems in the country. Massachusetts which
to many is one of the most liberal States in the Union also has the best school
system in the country. Who will suffer the most will be the ones who are already
suffering now. It will only get worse.
As a resident of Alabama, a mother of 2 grown children, and a disabled woman, I can confirm that the loss of federal oversight will exacerbate problems with existing discriminatory practices.
ReplyDelete